Qualitative GIS

By Susan J. Smith
294
2026

Description

Despite its relatively weak quantitative functionality, GIS is primarily associated with statistical and quantitative spatial analysis. This creates a particular representation of GIS as linked to traditional understandings of science and technology and, critically, to corporate power and institutions of control. In addition, constructing GIS as solely quantitative prevents it from being used for qualitative analysis, non-quantitative spatial analysis, and progressive research that often (although not always) relies upon non-quantitative research methods. GIS is, however, well suited for particular forms of qualitative research. For example, it allows for a rich visualization of information in the form of maps and other types of graphic data representation. In this sense, cutting-edge research in geovisualization is directly supporting non-quantitative uses of GIS. In addition to geovisualization, other recent research illustrates not only that a qualitative GIS is possible and growing but that it fulfills an important epistemological function. This function consists of the ability to visualize and investigate social phenomena that cannot be represented by quantitative databases (whether governmental, commercial, or user created) or analyzed by traditional quantitative and statistical techniques. Not only does qualitative GIS contribute to furthering our scientific understanding of the world by expanding the range of usable epistemologies, but it also supports research agendas that are committed to progressive politics and challenge the status quo. Finally, qualitative GIS also contributes to advances in social theory because it easily incorporates space into our thinking about the world and allows us to ask research questions that can only be addressed through mixed methods research. Qualitative geographic information systems (GIS) is a term representing diverse attempts to integrate qualitative data into existing GIS programs. Qualitative geographic information systems (qual-GIS) incorporates non quantitative data into GIS, integrates qualitative data collection and analysis with quantitative spatial analysis facilitated by GIS, adopts epistemologies typically associated with qualitative research, or a combination of these. Geographic Information Systems are an essential tool for analyzing and representing quantitative spatial data. Qualitative GIS explains the recent integration of qualitative research with Geographical Information Systems. With a detailed contextualising introduction, the text examines how researchers are using GIS to create new types of representations; working with spatial data, maps, and other visualizations to incorporate multiple meanings and to provide texture and context.

About Author

Professor Susan J. Smith has a distinguished career both as a human geographer and in the interdisciplinary world of housing studies. In addition to a programme of research spanning more than 30 years, Professor Smith is experienced in research management, research strategy, and research assessment of all kinds. She has contributed to the work of the ESRC (Research Grants Board, Professorial Fellowships Commissioning Panel, Public Services Programme Commissioning Panel), HEFCE (as a panel member in the 2001 and 2008 Research Assessment Exercises), the Leverhulme Trust (Philip Leverhulme Prize panel), and to research development and monitoring in HEIs within and beyond the UK. She has a wide-ranging teaching and examining portfolio, at all levels, in a variety of topics; and she is active in the communication dissemination of ideas beyond the academy.

Table of Content

 Preface
Chapter 1. Foundations of Qualitative GIS

Origins and Development of GIS as a Scientific Discipline
Differentiating Qualitative GIS from Quantitative GIS
Philosophical Underpinnings: Humanistic and Critical Geography
Role of Subjectivity and Reflexivity in Spatial Research
Paradigm Shift from Positivism to Post-Positivism in GIS

Chapter 2. Qualitative Data in GIS
Types of Qualitative Spatial Data
Integrating Field Notes and Ethnographies in GIS
Geo-Narratives and Spatial Storytelling
Participatory Mapping and Community Sketch Maps

Chapter 3. Methodologies in Qualitative GIS
Grounded Theory and Spatial Interpretation
Ethnographic Methods and Spatial Embedding
Visual Methodologies and Photo Mapping
Cognitive Mapping Techniques and Interpretation
Semi-Structured Interviews and Spatial Referencing

Chapter 4. Software and Tools For Qualitative GIS
Overview of GIS Software Supporting Qualitative Data
Using ArcGIS and QGIS for Narrative Mapping
Open-Source Tools for Participatory GIS
Multimedia and Hyperlinked GIS Layers

Chapter 5. Participatory GIS (PGIS)
Principles and Goals of PGIS
Power Dynamics in Map-Making
Indigenous Mapping and Cultural Preservation
Ethical Considerations in Participatory Projects
Pgis for Disaster Management and Response
Chapter 6. Feminist and Critical GIS
Feminist Perspectives on Spatial Representation
GIS and Intersectionality: Race, Gender, and Class
Embodied Mapping and Subjective Space
Deconstructing Cartesian Objectivity

 

Chapter 7. Narrative and Story Mapping
Spatial Storytelling as Methodology
Geospatial Narratives and ArcGIS Storymaps
Biographical and Life-Course Mapping
Emotional Cartography and Personal Geography

Chapter 8. Visualizing Qualitative Spatial Data
Cartographic Design for Non-Quantitative Data
Color Theory and Symbolism in Qualitative Maps
Non-Traditional Legend Creation and Interpretation
Designing for Interpretation and Engagement
Hybrid Visualizations: Text, Image, and Space

Chapter 9. Ethics in Qualitative GIS
Informed Consent in Spatial Research
Anonymity and Location Obfuscation Techniques
Sensitive Data and Cultural Boundaries
Ethics of Data Ownership in Indigenous Contexts
Dual Use Dilemma in Mapping
Institutional Review and Spatial Research

Chapter 10. Urban Applications of Qualitative GIS
Mapping Informality and Slum Geographies
Perceptions of Safety and Urban Fear Mapping
Community Perception Studies and Urban Planning
Gentrification Narratives and Displacement
Mapping Street Life and Public Space Use
Citizen-Generated Data in Urban Governance

Bibliography
Index